My quick and easy potato salad recipe can be made from scratch within 30 minutes! Best of all, this salad tastes delicious hot, warm, or cold! My whole family loves potato salad (especially me!). I just didn't like the traditional way of making it. It would take "forever". First, boil the potatoes. Cool. Peel. Slice. Prepare and gently mix in dressing.
This salad mimics the ones made by my Mutti from the northern part of Germany. That's why there's mayo in this German Potato Salad! What, you say? Mayonnaise? Yes, absolutely. Just the way it's made in many homes in the north. Check my comments below about this.
Oma's Easy Potato Salad Recipe
approx. 3 lb potatoes, cut up, approx. 8 cups
1 tsp salt
1 cup mayonnaise
½ cup liquid from dill pickles
¼ - 1 small onion, chopped (amount is your preference)
3 - 4 dill pickles, chopped (more or less to taste)
salt and pepper to season
dill weed to season
Wash and cut up unpeeled potatoes. Put in pot with hot water, 1 tsp salt, and bring to boil. Watch that it doesn't boil over (it foams).
Boil potatoes for about 10 minutes, until just tender. DO NOT OVERCOOK. Meanwhile, in serving bowl, add mayonnaise and pickle juice. Whisk until smooth.
Add chopped onion and dill pickle to dressing.
Drain potatoes when tender. Add to dressing in serving bowl. Mix gently.
Season with extra salt, pepper, and dill weed.
Serve hot, warm, or cold. The longer you let it stand, the more flavor is developed, but it does taste great immediately.
If you don't have hard boiled eggs ready, you can always add a couple of eggs into the water that's cooking the potatoes. The eggs will be done when the potatoes are done! Rinse them under cold water, peel, chop, and add.
Chopped celery, radishes, and apple (unpeeled) are nice additions to add.
Mayo in German Potato Salad?
Someone may be thinking, "This isn't German!" ... but it is. It's fashioned after the potato salad my Mutti made, and she's from Berlin.
In northern Germany, many of the potato salads are creamy (mayo-based) and in southern Germany, the salads have a bacon/vinegary/broth based dressing. However, this is not always the case. Some in the south use mayo, and some in the north like the bacon/vinegary ones.
Two completely different types of dressings. Both totally traditionally German!
Step-by-Step Method shown here ...
You'll love my method shown in the video below. This really quick and easy potato salad recipe has it all. It's tasty; it's quick; it's traditional; and, oh, so German!
Raw potatoes to finished salad in less than 30 minutes!
The Secret to quick ...
The secret in making this Kartoffelsalat is in cutting the washed, unpeeled, raw "new" potatoes into cubes - the size you want them in the salad.
Boil them until just tender - DO NOT OVERCOOK!
Meanwhile, make dressing and put into serving bowl. Add cooked, drained potato cubes. Stir. Enjoy!
Be careful when boiling potatoes, because they foam. You are losing some of the nutrients by cooking cut-up potatoes.
That happens anytime you cook cut vegetables. So, don't throw out the cooking water - refrigerate and save for soups.
Potato cooking water is especially good to use as liquid in gravies.
FYI: If you make a purchase via a link on this page, I may earn a small commission on the transaction - at NO added cost to you. That's how I keep these recipes FREE FOR YOU. Thanks for your support! Full disclosure policy here.
Affiliate Disclosure: Quick German Recipes participates in various affiliate advertising, including Amazon (amazon.com), to provide a means to earn advertising fees by linking to retail websites. We will not promote products we do no own or would not buy ourselves. Our goal is to provide you with product information and our own personal opinions or ideas. You should always perform due diligence before buying goods or services online. Quick German Recipes does not accept payment or merchandise from manufacturers in exchange for writing reviews.